Normal wear and tear vs. rental property damage: A complete guide

Confused by the differences between normal wear and tear and property damage? Learn all about it in our latest guide.
By
Minut
in
Hosting Advice
Calendar icon
July 30, 2024
5
min read
Normal wear and tear vs. rental property damage: A complete guide

As any property manager will know, a rental unit will rarely be pristine after years of being lived in. And while minor issues may arise, sometimes the line between fair wear and tear and property damage may be blurry. 

These gray areas can escalate quickly. Conflicts with residents over damages may lead to lengthy legal disputes, impact the property manager’s reputation, and potentially lead to financial loss. 

As a result, management teams need to have a clear understanding of what constitutes normal wear and tear and what is property damage.

In this guide, we outline the main differences between the two, explain how to plan for the effects of everyday use, and offer tips on preventing damage to a rental unit.

What constitutes normal wear and tear?

“Normal wear and tear” refers to the deterioration of a property resulting from residents’ everyday use. As a property manager, you should expect minor damages any time a property is rented out without making residents responsible for them.

Examples of normal wear and tear include:

  • Faded, chipped, or peeling paint or wallpaper
  • Frayed carpets or curtains
  • Minor scuffs or marks on walls or floors
  • Nail holes in walls
  • Faded shades
  • Loose doorknobs

Several factors will also impact the extent or severity of the property's wear and tear, such as: 

  • Length of the rental agreement: The longer residents stay in the property, the more wear and tear the property will likely experience.
  • Number of residents: Generally, more residents will lead to increased wear and tear.
  • Age of residents: The property will likely experience a higher degree of wear and tear if young children reside in it.
  • Presence of pets: Animals living in the property will speed up or worsen the deterioration of the interiors.
  • Age and quality of the property, materials, and furnishings: Newer or recently refurbished properties are more likely to withstand the effects of everyday use.

What constitutes property damage?

As opposed to fair wear and tear, property damage is significant and beyond the reasonable effects of everyday use. Residents will be held responsible for this type of damage, typically resulting from accidental or intentional negligence or carelessness.

Examples of property damage include:

  • Doors ripped off hinges
  • Broken windows
  • Broken appliances or furniture
  • Severely damaged, stained, or ruined wallpaper
  • Holes, stains, or burns in carpets
  • Gaping holes in walls
  • Deep scratches on floors
  • Unauthorized alterations

Deep cleaning or minor fixes cannot solve these issues, unlike with normal wear and tear. Instead, they require more time, expertise, and money to repair. Property damage may result in residents losing part or all of their security deposit or, in severe cases, lead to eviction. You may also have to escalate it to a legal dispute.

How to plan and budget for wear and tear

Reasonable wear and tear is inevitable in any living space. As a property manager, you must proactively deal with minor issues to keep the property in top shape.

So, where do you start?

Have a solid budget

Budgeting is the basis for the effective upkeep of a property and long-term operational success. There are several rules of thumb that property managers can follow, including:

  • 50% rule: Allocate half the monthly rental income to taxes, repairs and maintenance costs.
  • 1% rule: 1% of the annual property valuation will be destined to upkeep.
  • Square footage rule: Set aside $1 per square foot of the property for yearly maintenance expenses.

Set up routine inspections

Regular visits to the property allow you to stay on top of things as they come up (or even before they do) and repair them promptly, helping to prevent major problems in the future.

Know the lifecycle of furnishings and appliances

Bigger appliances, such as ovens, refrigerators, or microwaves, usually last between 10 and 15 years, while soft furnishings may have shorter lifespans. Curtains, for example, typically need to be replaced every three to five years. Keep track of when items were first used so you know when to get new ones.

Don’t forget about bigger repairs

The outside of a property is also subject to everyday deterioration. For instance, in single-family homes, exterior paint must be redone roughly every five to 10 years, and roofs need to be replaced every 15 to 25 years. It’s up to you to make sure you plan for these from both a scheduling and financial standpoint.

Keep communication flowing

Residents can give you a heads-up about any emerging problems, so make sure there’s always an open line of communication to detect issues early. Likewise, let them know in advance when an inspection is due or if work needs to be carried out.

How to avoid property damage

While you can’t anticipate when or if property damage will occur, there are several steps you can take to help minimize the chances of serious damage:  

  1. Set up periodic inspections: Regularly checking the property for any signs of potential problems—from plumbing to landscaping—will help detect and correct more minor details that could turn into major damage down the line. These inspections should be carried out when residents move in and out and every three to six months during their time at the property.
  1. Screen potential residents: Conduct thorough background checks on candidates before they move in and contact previous landlords or property managers to learn about any red flags.
  1. Educate residents: Provide appliance handbooks and maintenance guides to help them take care of the property adequately. Explain the procedures for reporting problems and encourage early communication.
  1. Make an in-depth inventory: Track the furnishings and appliances in the property and detail their state. Are they in perfect working order? Are they due for a replacement soon? Document these things clearly to avoid any potential disputes with residents.
  1. Pick materials and furnishings smartly: Prioritize resistant, hard-wearing materials and furniture to ensure they easily withstand use.
  1. Review your pet policies: Animals in the property increase the risk of damage, so having a more stringent pet policy and conducting pet screening will help prevent problems such as deeply stained carpets or worn-out furniture.
  1. Invest in the right tech to minimize risks: Parties and large gatherings are key risk factors for property damage. A solution like Minut can quickly make property managers aware of noise levels, occupancy, and cigarette smoke in the property and automatically contact residents to deal with any issues before they become a problem. With an indoor climate monitoring feature, Minut can also analyze temperature and humidity levels inside the unit, alerting you to mold risks before it’s too late. 

How to deal with property damage

Sometimes, despite the management team's best efforts, property damage occurs. Property managers can follow these steps to address it quickly:

Assess the damage: Conduct a thorough investigation of the property to understand the extent of the damage. Take pictures and videos to document the issues and have evidence in case of litigation.

Inform the residents: Notify the residents in writing, including a detailed description of the damages and adding images or videos to support your claims. Explain their responsibilities and contractual obligations as described in the lease agreement.

Repair the damages: Compare quotes from different providers and set clear repair timelines, ensuring the property is restored to its original condition. Record all costs and expenses relating to the works carried out.

Deduct the cost of repairs from the residents’ security deposit: Provide residents with a detailed list of the expenses being deducted, following local regulations to carry out the deductions.

Contact your insurance provider: If there is a policy on the property, file a claim where applicable, supplying supporting evidence.

Contact your legal team: If the residents refuse to take responsibility or dispute your claims, you will need help from a legal professional—and to support your case, you need evidence. Images and videos are essential (especially if you can supply ‘before and after’ material for comparison). Additionally, Minut’s event reports can be used where cigarette smoke, occupancy, noise, and humidity levels are part of the claim.

Stay on top of wear and tear and minimize risk factors for your portfolio

Managing a property portfolio successfully is all about prevention. As a property manager, it’s up to you to stay on top of repairs and act promptly on any major issues before they escalate.  Doing so is the best way to both keep a property in good shape and make sure residents are happy. 

Likewise, minimizing risk factors for property damage, from smoking to partying, is crucial. Minut can help you do precisely this, with real-time alerts that let property managers take action as soon as issues emerge.

Discover why over 50,000 property managers choose Minut to help them look after properties around the world. Book a demo today.